Home Guides Jess Varnish: Ex-cyclist’s hearing ‘should not fear Bosman ruling’
Guides

Jess Varnish: Ex-cyclist’s hearing ‘should not fear Bosman ruling’

By Alistair MagowanBBC Sport

Last updated on .From the section Cycling

\"Jess

Jess Varnish’s employment tribunal appeal hearing has been told it should not fear a Bosman-style ruling just because of the disruption it may cause.

Varnish, 29, is appealing after failing to prove she was an employee of British Cycling or funding body UK Sport.

The British former cyclist then intends to sue for discrimination after being dropped for the 2016 Rio Olympics.

During the initial hearing, British Cycling’s lawyer warned “the skies would fall in” should Varnish win.

The lawyer argued that it could lead to other athletes suing UK Sport.

But tribunal appeal lay member Peter Hunter, who will assist ruling judge Mr Justice Choudhury, said: “The potential disruption is irrelevant.”

Hunter said he was “surprised” neither side had mentioned the landmark case of Jean-Marc Bosman, who successfully challenged football’s transfer rules at the European Court in 1995 on the basis of restraint of trade.

It fundamentally changed the way clubs treated footballers – by allowing them to leave for free at the end of their contracts.

Hunter added: “I’m a football fan and I think [Bosman] had a very disruptive effect on football and one can see the potential disruption [here] but it’s irrelevant.

“Bosman was legally right and the question here is what is legally correct.”

Varnish lost her case in January 2019 following the initial hearing, but won the right to appeal last December.

The result of the appeal, which took place over video link on Tuesday and Wednesday, is not expected for between three and 10 weeks.

It could lead to the original decision being overturned, a second tribunal needing to take place with three panel judges rather than one, or the original decision being upheld.

Varnish’s legal team, led by David Reade QC, is arguing that the contract between British Cycling and the former European team sprint champion was akin to that of an employer-employee relationship.

British Cycling said the relationship was “that of an organisation supporting talented and dedicated athletes to achieve their best” and funding was more like a university grant.

But Reade said that analogy fell down because of the control which British Cycling exerted over riders such as Varnish.

He argued: “It’s true that in the context of university, if I’m a student I may enter into a contract to get the benefit of tuition or lecturing. There’s no question the university is providing services.

“But under the contract with a university, is there a contractual commitment on the part of student to attend lectures and tutorials? Is there any commitment of a student to sit exams that the university stipulates?

“Do they need to wear the university logo or allow their image to be used in the media for the purposes of the university?

“None of those things are present.”

Related Articles

Clipless Pedals for Road Cycling Beginne...
Road Cycling

Clipless Pedals for Road Cycling Beginne...

You have seen them. Riders clipped in feet locked to the pedals. They pedal in smooth circles, they pull up as well as push down. It looks efficient and scary. Here is the truth. Clipless pedals are not hard to learn

Latest Cycling Technology Trends Every R...
Cycling

Latest Cycling Technology Trends Every R...

The cycling world never stops moving. Every year brings new ideas. Some are gimmicks. Some change how we ride. The latest cycling technology trends are all about smart tech. AI motors that adjust to your body. Radars that warn you of cars. Jerseys

Best Bike Multitool for Long Distance Cy...
Tips & Reviews

Best Bike Multitool for Long Distance Cy...

You are fifty miles from home and something goes wrong. A bolt rattles loose. Your saddle shifts. Your chain snaps. Without the best bike multitool for long distance cycling, you are stuck. You walk or you call for a ride. With

Cycling Clothes for Beginners: What You ...
Guides

Cycling Clothes for Beginners: What You ...

Walking into a bike shop and looking at cycling clothes is overwhelming. Padded shorts that cost a fortune. Jerseys in every color. Gloves, jackets, base layers. It is too much. But here is the truth. You do not need most